James Vowles gives his honest verdict on whether Kimi Antonelli was promoted into F1 too early

Follow us on Google Discover

Six drivers were entering their first full Formula 1 seasons at the beginning of 2025, but none attracted more interest than Mercedes’ Andrea Kimi Antonelli.

When Lewis Hamilton announced he would be leaving Mercedes to join Ferrari for the 2025 F1 season, there was plenty of speculation about who would replace him.

Carlos Sainz was linked with Mercedes, and plenty of other drivers would have jumped at the chance of racing for Toto Wolff.

But, in the end, Wolff handed his young protege, Kimi Antonelli, the chance to impress in Formula 1 just two years after he was racing in Formula Regional.

The teenager skipped Formula 3 entirely, and while Antonelli showed glimpses of his potential in F2, he didn’t challenge Gabriel Bortoleto and Isack Hadjar for the championship.

When Antonelli took part in the Australian Grand Prix at the start of the season, he became the third-youngest person to race in Formula 1, behind Max Verstappen and Lance Stroll.

At times this year, it’s been clear that the Italian has felt the pressure, but Williams team principal James Vowles has now shared whether he thinks Mercedes made the right decision promoting him as quickly as they did.

READ MORE: Know all about 2025 Mercedes F1 driver Andrea Kimi Antonelli including stats

James Vowles backs Mercedes’ decision to give Andrea Kimi Antonelli his F1 debut this season

Vowles was asked on the F1 Nation podcast whether he believed drivers like Antonelli were being pushed through too quickly into Formula 1.

He replied: “For what it’s worth, you saw Kimi coming back more in the second half of the year.

“So, it probably tells you he’s learning very quickly, but he is learning, and he wasn’t up to speed immediately.

“I think here’s the biggest difference for me. The grid in Monza, I think, was eight-tenths separating all of us. The difference now from before is, in the previous world, you could make a small mistake.

“A small mistake would be a tenth or two-tenths, and probably still qualify one position behind your teammate. It’s not the end of the world, is it?

“You do that now, and you qualify five positions behind your teammate. It’s a completely different world from where we were.

“Do I think they’re being pushed too early? It depends on what your agenda is. If Mercedes’ agenda, and I think it was, was that 2025 is a year that they know they’re not going to be the strongest, but 2026 is.

“You need to forward invest in your driver at that point in time. As long as you have the right construct around them, and you support them all the way through the process, they’ll come out the other side alive.”

READ MORE: Everything you need to know about Williams team principal James Vowles including education and net worth

James Vowles shares whether the F1 superlicense age should be increased from 18

It was then put to Vowles that the superlicense age may be too low at 18, and he used Antonelli as the perfect example.

He explained: “I think we’re in a good place now. I think 18 is a sensible place to be.

“I’ll put it to you differently. If Kimi weren’t in a Mercedes and he were in a different team, it wouldn’t have been with us, but somewhere else.

“So he was less in the limelight, but he was learning his way through. I think the world would have accepted that’s fine.

“That’s just part of the journey because that used to be how you’re doing these things.

“So does he have a place in Formula 1? 100%, and was he fine at 18 and mature enough at 18 to go there? Yes, I think so as well. So the age doesn’t concern me.”

Red Bull got special dispensation for Arvid Lindblad to be given a superlicense at 17 in case he was needed to step up into Formula 1 with Verstappen on the cusp of a one-race ban.

The Dutchman is the ultimate example of if you’re good enough, you’re old enough, although the ever-increasing pressure on F1 drivers, both in the paddock and on social media, means that they have to mature quickly in the spotlight.

Antonelli admits putting unnecessary pressure on himself at Imola, when he took on too many commitments outside of racing before his home Grand Prix.

He’s learning quickly, though, and as Vowles has suggested, more than proved he’s good enough to be racing in Formula 1 this year.